Barriers at Xmas Tree (to break containment)

Discussion Forum > Well Control > Barriers at Xmas Tree (to break containment)

Barriers at Xmas Tree (to break containment)

Dear all

We are preparing for a complicated snubbing fishing programme and we have just received a request that we'd like the members opinion on.

The GAS well is compromised with a plugged completion. Potentially 6000 psi surface pressure.
We are being requested to break the wing valve off the tree to rotate an instrument block.
There are no spares and no people to assist

Question: If we test the LMV from above with water and keep it closed and then test the UMV with water from above does that constitute an acceptable double barrier?

I feel not but………I may be wrong?

Testing gate valves from the wrong side – is that considered an acceptable barrier to permit breaking off the wing valve? This is a gas well and we are testing with water.

As usual it is not as straightforward because we have fish and a plugged completion ………12 months ago. And nobody has a clue what state the well is in now.

We are concerned about breaking the tree integrity, because we can foresee potential damage to the ring groove and we have no spares!

I would be interested to hearing opinions on what can be accepted as barrier.

I need an opinion ASAP, please.