T&D Analysis - Buckling

Opinion Needed:
Performed T&D on an S shaped well on Well Plan on an 8-3/8" BHA, where buckling limit is predicted near the depth the well starts to become vertical. [ Max inclination ~ 15 deg]. Weight to buckle the string helically ~ 5 T in the analysis, on which drilling is operationally not feasible. To double check the results, SLB & HLB were asked to perform the analysis, where SLB results showed the onset of helical buckling at 15 T [ significantly higher value], but HLB results were same as our's [maybe because they use the same software i.e. Well plan] Is it because of different algorithms used for buckling in both the software? What might be the reasons?
Inclination profile and analysis results are attached
P.S All three analysis used the Stiff String model and same friction factors

Documents uploaded by user:

BW X-1 Inclination.jpg

Well Plan BW X-1 Buckle.jpg

SLB BW X-1 Buckle.jpg

9 Answer(s)

---